Blog Layout

Systems and Strategy: Causal Maps, Complexity, and Strategic Competition

Dr. Christopher Ford • November 17, 2022

MITRE's Center for Strategic Competition (CSC) published its seventh Occasional Paper on November 14, 2022.  Written by Dr. Ford, it describes some of the ways in which the CSC has been working to develop approaches to understanding decision making through the prism of Complexity Science, and offers an illustrative hypothetical example of how such methods can enrich policymaking.  The paper can be found here, or can be downloaded by using the button below.

From the Executive Summary:


In developing and implementing an effective ‘whole of nation’ (WON) response to the WON challenges we face in the modern world, such as those presented by China’s full- spectrum competitive strategy, it is essential to provide U.S. and other Western leaders with the holistic situational awareness, ‘systems’-informed analysis, and cross-jurisdictional policy coordination that a genuinely ‘comprehensive’ national strategy—and strategic ‘campaigning’—requires. China’s effort to create what might be called a ‘leverage web of mutually-reinforcing instruments of power and influence confronts U.S. leaders with a genuinely systemic problem of long-term competitive strategy. Yet the U.S. Government is presently not well organized to meet this challenge ....


We need much more sophisticated ways to assess and describe our strategic environment, to understand key patterns and dynamics therein that affect U.S. interests—including the systemic patterns that can be generated by and within complex systems—to evaluate possible courses of action (COAs) in response to developments, to identify ways to wield coordinated levers of national power in response to strategic challenges, to monitor the impact of policy interventions upon that environment, and to repeat such analysis and COA evaluation on a timely and iterated basis so as to ensure that U.S. responses fit the situation. ...


The MITRE Corporations Center for Strategic Competition has been working to develop and refine methodologies to help: (1) find ways to aggregate the input of multiple Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) in a scalable way through the construction and aggregation of causal maps; and (2) understand such causal maps in ways that identify characteristic patterns therein in order to focus policy deliberations upon the development of effective interventions designed to break, impede, or nudge such systemic dynamics
in more salutary directions. This approach allows a considerable degree of complexity to be intelligibly captured, while yet permitting one to
‘unpack’ advice given on the basis of such maps in detail, allowing leaders to assess its plausibility, identify its underlying assumptions, spot the areas of relative consensus or contestation encoded therein, test counterfactuals against received wisdoms, and explore the merits and demerits of alternative policy interventions in a rigorous and systematic way. Using such tools, it is also possible to discern and visualize the most significant sub-system interrelationships in a complex system such as that of People’s Republic of China (PRC) global strategy. Identifying characteristic configurations and the dynamics that may lie behind systemic behavior can help open up important new insights into strategy and possibilities for policy interventions. ....”


DOWNLOAD Systems and Strategy
By Dr. Christopher Ford February 21, 2025
Below is the text upon which Dr. Ford based his remarks to a conference at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory on February 20, 2025.
By Dr. Christopher Ford February 18, 2025
Below is the text upon which Dr. Ford based his remarks on February 18, 2025, to a Track 2 dialogue with Russia on Military Risk Reduction in Europe.
By Dr. Christopher Ford February 6, 2025
On February 6, 2025, the Center for Global Security Research at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory published a new edited volume on nuclear weapons challenges in the Middle East. Dr. Ford's paper "Snapping Back and Looking Forward: A New Old Approach to the Iran Nuclear Crisis" appears in that volume. You can find the whole book on CGSR's website here , or use the button below to download Dr. Ford's chapter. 
By Dr. Christopher Ford January 30, 2025
Below is the prepared text upon which Dr. Ford drew in his panel discussion for an even sponsored by the New York State Bar Association on "Nuclear Weapons and International Law" on January 30, 2025.
By Dr. Christopher Ford January 23, 2025
Below is the text upon which Dr. Ford based his remarks to the workshop on “Enhancing Regional Security and Addressing WMD Threats in the Middle East,” held in Abu Dhabi, UAE, on January 23, 2023. 
By Dr. Christopher Ford December 31, 2024
With 2024 hours from being over, here’s a handy compilation of my public work product from the last year. As you can see from the list of seven papers or articles and 20 presentations below, it’s been a big year for nuclear weapons policy and arms control topics – but as always there’s a good helping of strategic competition with China. Keep checking New Paradigms Forum for new material as we move into 2025. And Happy New Year, everyone!
By Dr. Christopher Ford December 24, 2024
Below is an edited and revised version of the remarks Dr. Ford prepared for a CSIS/PONI Workshop on “Irreversibility in Nuclear Disarmament” at Wilton Park, in the United Kingdom, on December 18, 2024.
By Dr. Christopher Ford December 17, 2024
Below are the remarks Dr. Ford delivered to the annual so-called “Nukes at Christmas” nonproliferation conference at Wilton Park, United Kingdom, on December 16, 2024.
By Dr. Christopher Ford December 15, 2024
Below is the text upon which Dr. Ford based his remarks at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars on December 13, 2024.
By Dr. Christopher Ford December 12, 2024
Below are the remarks Dr. Ford delivered to a conference at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory on December 11, 2024, organized by the Center for Global Security Research (CGSR).
More Posts
Share by: